exciting, informative, snarky, and very likely fabricated tales of life as an american expat in london

watching the english

by Jen at 12:32 pm on 5.02.2007 | 4 Comments
filed under: classic, londonlife

as amity was chatting on the phone to her family back in the states after the game, i was exploring her bookshelves, and stumbled across a book i’d been meaning to read for ages: “watching the english”, by kate fox. it’s a book that’s often spoken of amongst expats as an anthropological study on the unique customs and social mores of the english – recommended reading by way of imparting some insight. i’d never gotten around to picking it up, but was flipping through the pages last night and found myself intrigued enough to borrow it.

and though i am only about 50 pages in, i’m finding it really depressing. you see, after living and working here for 4 years now, i kind of felt that i’d achieved some semblance of integration. that i’d been around long enough not to stand out like a sore thumb. god help me, people back in the states even say i’ve picked up some british inflection to my words (not to mention adopted much of the vocabulary and spelling quite early on – a byproduct of needing to communicate clearly and write lots of reports for my job). i’ve never consciously set out to try to assimilate, but it’s only natural that after a certain period of time a lot of stuff has rubbed off on me. i’ve never deliberately set out to “fit in”. but i’d hoped that i did, just a little.

and now those hopes have been thoroughly dashed. the author’s insights and explorations of the “unwritten rules” of english society are so precisely accurate, yet so convoluted, that i despair of ever really hoping to successfully navigate them. so much of what i find intensely frustrating about being an outsider is a product of societal law so deeply ingrained, yet so unspoken, that a culture clash with my personality and modus operandi is inevitable. one must never appear too eager. one must never reveal too much. one must never openly disagree. one must never be overly informal or overly friendly. i can learn these rules, but i’ll never be able to live them.

but if i’m honest, none of this is news to me. in work situations, i find myself constantly trying to modulate between being too outspoken, and not piping up enough. i chime in at the wrong times, create awkward silences, inadvertently step on toes. i’m constantly second guessing myself and trying to tone it down, where “it” is my normal forthright manner of speaking/thinking/doing. i’m ever conscious of trying not to come across as the stereotypical “brash american”, but chafing inside at not being able to just be myself, no matter how others interpret that. i vacillate between trying to break free of the preconceptions that come with my accent, and just saying “fuck it – this is who i am. accept it.”

and in the end, i’m realising none of it really matters. that the way i come across won’t ever change much, because there’s a finite limit to how much *i* can change. or more accurately, i’m realising there’s a limit to how much i’m *willing* to change. i will never understand the mustn’t grumble ethos, even in the face of valid cause for complaint. i will never understand the national reservedness, or the impulse to conform at all cost. i refuse to buy into the class distinctions, and i will most likely never be able to distinguish a posh accent from a blue-collar one. it took me years to find confidence and assertiveness, and ditch the meek, awkward person i was until i hit my mid-20s. why on earth would i want to give that up just to blend in?

still, it’s discouraging to see people wince when i’m in a meeting and say something too bluntly. it’s disheartening to try to make friends yet not be able to break through the wall of reserve of people i otherwise really like. to know that no matter how regularly i say “toe-mahh-toe” people will still hear my accent and draw conclusions about me. all the studying in the world won’t get me past those obstacles, and they may never even get any better, no matter how long i am here. i just don’t know the rules. i’m not being a rebel, just a naif.

i can watch the english, observe the customs, study the rules – but it seems i’ll never learn.

song of the day: Califone – The Orchids

Audio clip: Adobe Flash Player (version 9 or above) is required to play this audio clip. Download the latest version here. You also need to have JavaScript enabled in your browser.

Technorati Tags
4 Comments »

4 Comments

  • 1

    Comment by Avril

    5.02.2007 @ 14:47 pm

    Don’t change – you are who you are. People here are so boring, never say what they mean, never ask for what they really want. Don’t ever get to be like that.

  • 2

    Comment by Anglofille

    6.02.2007 @ 01:20 am

    i found this book to be extremely annoying and didn’t even finish it. i’m sure there’s some truth in it, but i think it also just perpetuates stereotypes. i read a few books like this on french culture before i moved to paris. and nearly everything i read has been proven wrong by my own first-hand experiences.

  • 3

    Comment by LindsayM

    6.02.2007 @ 13:19 pm

    Bleh. That book made me so self-conscious, I never realised I gave out so many clues about being “working class” and therefore “inferior”.

    It definitely perpetuates tired old stereotypes that lots of English people don’t fit into and don’t even care much for. Mostly I see it as yet another example to define “Englishness” to work out a set of rules that exclude the outsider, but also exclude English people who are too busy getting on with their lives to learn the rules.

  • 4

    Comment by Amity

    6.02.2007 @ 16:05 pm

    I guess I didn’t let the book affect me in that way, in fact, i never thought about it like that — that i’m an ‘outsider’ who won’t ever know all these rules. we’ll never be english, we’ll always stand out, we’ll never fully understand the culture. but is that such a bad thing? sometimes ignorance is bliss.

RSS feed for comments on this post